Comparison of Clinical Efficacy of Simultaneous Proton and Heavy Ion Radiotherapy Between Cisplatin and Nedaplatin in the Treatment of Nasopharyngeal Malignant Tumor
XU Meng, ZHAI Qing. Comparison of Clinical Efficacy of Simultaneous Proton and Heavy Ion Radiotherapy Between Cisplatin and Nedaplatin in the Treatment of Nasopharyngeal Malignant Tumor[J]. 2020,20(8):910-913.
XU Meng, ZHAI Qing. Comparison of Clinical Efficacy of Simultaneous Proton and Heavy Ion Radiotherapy Between Cisplatin and Nedaplatin in the Treatment of Nasopharyngeal Malignant Tumor[J]. 2020,20(8):910-913. DOI: 10.14009/j.issn.1672-2124.2020.08.004.
OBJECTIVE:Replacing cisplatin by nedaplatin for single-week simultaneous proton and heavy ion radiotherapy
so as to compare with cisplatin for simultaneous proton and heavy ion radiotherapy in the treatment of nasopharyngeal malignant tumor in terms of efficacy
adverse drug reactions and pharmacoeconomics.METHODS:91 patients with nasopharyngeal malignant tumor receiving simultaneous proton and heavy ion radiotherapy of cisplatin(cisplatin group
46 cases) and nedaplatin(nedaplatin group
45 cases) admitted into Fudan University Shanghai Cancer Certer Proton and Heavy Ion Center from Jan.2017 to Jun.2019 were collected
differences in efficacy
adverse drug reactions and costs were compared between two groups.RESULTS:The effective rate and clinical benefit rate of cisplatin group were respectively 73.91%(34/46) and 93.48%(43/46)
while the effective rate and clinical benefit rate of cisplatin group were respectively 75.56%(34/45) and 93.33%(42/45);there were no statistical significance in differences in effective rate and clinical benefit rate between two groups(P>0.05).The incidences of hemoglobin reduction
electrolyte imbalance
kidney damage
nausea and vomiting in the cisplatin group were significantly higher than those in nedaplatin group
with statistically significant differences(P < 0.05).The cost of chemotherapy alone in cisplatin group was significantly lower than that in nedaplatin group
with statistically significant differences(P<0.05);while there was no statistical significance in difference in total costs between two groups(P>0.05).CONCLUSIONS:The short-term efficacy and total cost of simultaneous proton and heavy ion radiotherapy of cisplatin and nedaplatin in the treatment of nasopharyngeal malignant tumor are equivalent
but nedaplatin has significantly fewer adverse drug reactions.
关键词
鼻咽恶性肿瘤顺铂奈达铂质子重离子疗效
Keywords
Nasopharyngeal malignant tumorCisplatinNedaplatinProton and heavy ionEfficacy