Systematic review on the efficacy and safety of warfarin compared with placebo and heparin for the prevention of central venous catheters-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer
WANG Song, et al. Systematic review on the efficacy and safety of warfarin compared with placebo and heparin for the prevention of central venous catheters-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer[J]. Journal of Chongqing Medical University, 2011,36(3):367-371.
WANG Song, et al. Systematic review on the efficacy and safety of warfarin compared with placebo and heparin for the prevention of central venous catheters-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer[J]. Journal of Chongqing Medical University, 2011,36(3):367-371. DOI: 10.13406/j.cnki.cyxb.2011.03.033.
Objective:To evaluate the efficacy and safety of warfarin for the prevention of central venous catheters-associated(CVCs-associated) thrombosis in patients with cancer systematically via a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and(or) clinical controlled trials on warfarin for the prevention of CVCs-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer
and to provide theoretical basis for the clinical prevention of CVCs-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer.Methods:Databases including MEDLINE
OVID
EBSCO
EMBASE
CBM and CNKI were searched
and at the same time
reference retrieval and manual searching were used to acquire basic data.For the literatures which met the inclusion criteria
methodology quality assessment was performed and data information was extracted.A meta-analysis was done by RevMan 5.0.25 statistical software.Results:Seven randomized controlled trials and clinical controlled trials were included.There were six literatures(including 1 522 patients with cancer) about warfarin vs.placebo and one literature(including 45 cancer patients) about warfarin vs.heparin.The results of systematic review were showed as follows:1.In Warfarin vs.placebo
the difference of CVCs-associated thrombosis incidence had statistical significance between the two groups(RR=0.68
95%CI[0.52
0.89];P=0.004).However
the difference of bleeding incidence and mortality rate had no statistical significance
with bleeding incidence(RR=2.12
95%CI[0.82
5.48];P=0.12) and mortality rate(RR=1.01
95%CI[0.58
1.74];P=0.98).2.In Warfarin vs.heparin
the difference of CVCs-associated thrombosis incidence
bleeding incidence and mortality rate had no statistical significance
with the incidence of CVCs-associated thrombosis(RR=0.58
95%CI[0.19
1.79];P=0.35)
bleeding incidence(RR=0.29
95%CI[0.01
6.84];P=0.45)
and mortality rate(RR=0.58
95%CI[0.19
1.79];P=0.35).Conclusion:Warfarin
compared with placebo
is effective and safe in the prevention of CVCs-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer.Warfarin can decrease CVCs-associated thrombosis incidence of patients with cancer effectively and does not increase bleeding incidence or mortality rate.In Warfarin vs.heparin
the efficacy and safety are equal in the prevention of CVCs-associated thrombosis in patients with cancer.But because of scanty related studies
more randomized controlled trials with strict design and large samples are still needed to further raise the intensity of proof.