Plate versus intramedullary nailing in the treatment of distal tibial fracture in adults:a Meta-analysis

Luo Mingyan; Tang Fang; Fan Weijie; Wu Yaqiong; Ouyang Peng; Zhou Kewei

doi:10.13406/j.cnki.cyxb.001110

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Plate versus intramedullary nailing in the treatment of distal tibial fracture in adults:a Meta-analysis

更新时间：2024-01-17

- Plate versus intramedullary nailing in the treatment of distal tibial fracture in adults:a Meta-analysis
- Journal of Chongqing Medical University Vol. 42, Issue 2, Pages: 169-175(2017)
- 作者机构：
  
  1. 南华大学附属第一医院骨科
  2. 河南省驻马店市正阳县人民医院骨科
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：10.13406/j.cnki.cyxb.001110
  CLC： R687.3
- Published：2017，
扫描看全文
Luo Mingyan, Tang Fang, Fan Weijie, et al. Plate versus intramedullary nailing in the treatment of distal tibial fracture in adults:a Meta-analysis. [J]. Journal of Chongqing Medical University 42(2):169-175(2017)
DOI：

Luo Mingyan, Tang Fang, Fan Weijie, et al. Plate versus intramedullary nailing in the treatment of distal tibial fracture in adults:a Meta-analysis. [J]. Journal of Chongqing Medical University 42(2):169-175(2017) DOI： 10.13406/j.cnki.cyxb.001110.

摘要

目的:Meta分析比较钢板与髓内钉治疗成人胫骨远端骨折的疗效。方法:计算机检索Pub Med、Embase、Ovid、Medline、Science Direct、the Cochrane Library（2015年11期）、知网、万方等数据库。根据纳入和剔除标准筛选出符合要求的文献。以术后全部并发症率、感染率、畸形愈合率和延迟或不愈合率为主要分析指标

用Review Manager 5.3软件进行Meta分析。结果:纳入文献16篇

共1 919例胫骨远端骨折（钢板组773例

髓内钉组1 146例）。Meta分析结果提示胫骨远端骨折

钢板组术后全部并发症率与髓内钉组无统计学差异（OR=0.68

95%CI=0.44

.05

P=0.080）;术后感染率

钢板组高于髓内钉组

有统计学差异（OR=1.85

95%CI=1.21

.84

P=0.005）;术后畸形愈合率

钢板组低于髓内钉组

有统计学差异（OR=0.34

95%CI=0.21

.50

P=0.000）;延迟或不愈合率

钢板组低于髓内钉组

有统计学差异（OR=0.50

95%CI=0.30

.83

P=0.007）。结论:钢板治疗或髓内钉治疗均是成人胫骨远端骨折治疗中常用的术式

各有优缺点

目前尚不能得出哪种治疗方式更科学。当骨折伴软组织损伤较重时推荐使用髓内钉治疗

可降低术后感染率;当骨折旋转稳定性差时推荐使用钢板治疗

可降低术后延迟愈合或不愈合发生率。

Abstract

Objective:To compare the efficacy of plate versus intramedullary nailing for distal tibial fracture by Meta-analysis. Methods:Databases of Pub Med

Embase

Ovid

Medline

Science Direct

the Cochrane Library（Issue 11

2015）

Wanfang Data and CNKI were searched. The keywords were tibial fractures

fracture fixation

intramedullary nailing and plate. Full text was screened and downloaded. Retrieval time was from database built to November 2015 in all databases. According to inclusion and exclusion criteria

literature meeting the requirements was screened. The post-operative complication rate

infection rate

deformity healing rate and delay or bone un-union rate were taken as the main observation indexes. The Review Manager 5.3 software was used for Meta-analysis.Results:A total of 16 studies were included

including 1 919 distal tibial fractures（plate group:773 fractures;intramedullary nailing group:1 146 fractures）. Meta-analysis results showed that there was no statistical significance in total postoperative complication rate between plate group versus intramedullary nailing group（OR=0.68

95%CI=0.44 to 1.05

P=0.080）. Postoperative infection rate was higher in plate group than in intramedullary nailing group（OR=1.85

95%CI=1.21 to 2.84

P=0.005）. Postoperative deformity healing rate was lower in plate group than in intramedullary nailing group（OR=0.34

95%CI=0.21 to 0.50

P=0.000）. Postoperative bone delayed union or un-union rate was lower in plate group than in intramedullary nailing group（OR=0.50

95%CI=0.30 to 0.83

P=0.007）.Conclusion:Plate and intramedullary nail are common implant materials in the treatment of distal tibial fractures

each have advantages and disadvantages. With the limited information available at present

no evidence confirmed what kind of treatment is more scientific. Intramedullary nailing treatment is recommended when fracture combining with serious soft tissue injury. Plate treatment can reduce the incidence of post-operative delayed union or un-union when fracture combing with poor rotational stability.

关键词

胫骨骨折内固定髓内钉钢板Meta分析

Keywords

tibial fractureinternal fixationintramedullary nailbone platesMeta-analysis

references

Views

208

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

The efficacy and safety of argatroban in the treatment of acute ischemic stroke: a systematic review and Meta-analysis

Effect of displacement degree of single butterfly fracture fragment on the healing of femoral shaft fracture treated with intramedullary nail

Effectiveness of acupuncture combined with donepezil for Alzheimer's disease: a Meta-analysis

Efficacy of absorbable cartilage screws internal fixation in treatment of tibial intercondylar eminence fracture in children

Efficiency of the occipitocervical fusion for occipitocervical instability

Related Author

Yinqin Hu

Jiwei Cheng

Meng Sun

Guoyi Li

Qian Xiao

Zhaoyang Yin

Shuo Yang

Yongfeng Huo

Related Institution

Department of Neurology，Putuo Hospital，Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine

Department of Orthopaedics, Xuzhou Medical University Affiliated Hospital of Lianyungang

Department of Orthopaedics,the Affiliated Jiangning Hospital of Nanjing Medical University

Department of Neurology, Ruijin Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine

Department of Acupuncture, Ruijin Hospital Affiliated to Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine

⁰