Objective To evaluate the effect of combined teaching of optical laryngoscope and general laryngoscope on anesthesia undergraduate practice. Methods A total of 40 anesthesia undergraduate students were randomly divided into group A (using the optical laryngocope only in the first month and the general laryngoscope only in the second month
n=20)
and group B (using the general laryngocope only in the first month and the optical laryngoscope only in the second month
n=20). The teaching effect was evaluated through the first month and the second month of tracheal intubation assessment and questionnaire survey results. SPSS 23.0 was used for t test and chi-square test. Results In the first month
the success rate was 90% in group A and 60% in group B
which showed that the success rate of group B was lower
with significant differences (P < 0.05). The time for tracheal intubation in group A was (61.8±5.0) s
and that in the group B was (83.0±4.9) s
showing that the time of group B was longer
with significant differences (P < 0.05). The complications in group A was 5%
and that in group B was 14%
showing that the group B had more cases of implications
with significant differences (P < 0.05). In the second month
there was no significant difference in the one-time success rate
the time for tracheal intubation
and complications between the two groups (P > 0.05). There was no significant difference in one-time success rate and complications between groups. Both groups showed that the time for general laryngoscope intubation was longer
with significant differences (P < 0.05). All of the students believed that applying optical laryngoscope teaching was beneficial and could enhance the interest of learning
and the combination of the two methods was better. Conclusion Using the optical laryngoscope first and then the general laryngoscope teaching is more beneficial for students to master the two methods of tracheal intubation
improve the success rate
reduce complications
and cultivates their self-confidence.
关键词
气管插管 可视喉镜 普通喉镜 实习教学 麻醉学专业
Keywords
Tracheal intubation Optical laryngoscope General laryngoscope Practice teaching Anesthesiology