Wu Xiaobo,Zhang Qi,Guo Mingke,Zhang Yingze.Biomechanical comparison of 4 plate internal fixation methods for simulated fractures of acetabular posterior column[J].J Amry Med Univ (J Third Mil Med Univ),2010,32(07):665-668.
Wu Xiaobo,Zhang Qi,Guo Mingke,Zhang Yingze.Biomechanical comparison of 4 plate internal fixation methods for simulated fractures of acetabular posterior column[J].J Amry Med Univ (J Third Mil Med Univ),2010,32(07):665-668.DOI:
Objective To evaluate the stability of 4 different methods of plate internal fixation for simulated posterior column fracture of the acetabulum. Methods Twenty preserved cadaveric semipelvic specimens were divided into 4 groups randomly. Models of isolated posterior column fractures of acetabulum were established and then fixed with 1 of following 4 methods of plate internal fixation: 2 screws at the each end of plate (group A)
3 screws at the each end of plate (group B)
1 screw each side in the closest allowable hole to the fracture and 2 screws at the each end of plate (group C)
and 4 screws on each side of the fracture (group D). Under vertical compression load of 3 times’ body weight
the displacements of the fracture site were measured and the shear rigidity of different internal fixation methods were compared. Results The displacements of the fracture site in Group A
B
C
and D were 4.68±0.35
2.80±0.25
2.12±0.11 and 1.58±0.17 mm respectively
with a decreasing trend from Group A to D. The shear rigidity of internal fixation methods in Group A
B
C
and D were 129.42±9.60
228.91±12.05
285.21±26.16 and 414.71±34.29 N/mm respectively
with an increasing trend from Group A to D. The differences of both displacements and shear rigidity between each 2 groups were significant (P0.05). The stability of fixation methods in different groups was reached its maximum in Group D. Conclusion Under the prerequisite of safe angle of screw placement
holes on the plate in the danger zone of acetabulum
especially the ones being closest to either side of the fracture line
should be fixed in order to attain rigid internal fixation for posterior column fractures of the acetabulum.