Analysis of the concealed evaluation results of academic dissertations in a medical university

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Analysis of the concealed evaluation results of academic dissertations in a medical university

更新时间：2024-09-19

- Analysis of the concealed evaluation results of academic dissertations in a medical university
- Vol. 18, Issue 10, Pages: 1053-1064(2019)
- 作者机构：
  
  陆军军医大学研究生院,重庆
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：
  CLC：
- Published：2019，
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
Analysis of the concealed evaluation results of academic dissertations in a medical university. [J]. 18(10):1053-1064(2019)
DOI：

Analysis of the concealed evaluation results of academic dissertations in a medical university. [J]. 18(10):1053-1064(2019) DOI：

摘要

目的　通过分析研究生学位论文盲审结果，探索学位论文分项质量差异，为提高学位论文质量提供参考。方法　选取某医学院校366篇学位论文1 051篇双盲评阅书，根据研究生学位论文评价指标体系，按总体质量和学科门类进行横向比较，采用Excel、SPSS 19.0进行数据统计分析。结果　不合格类中80%的论文选题较差，其规范性优良率仅为21%；在学科分项评价中，“选题”上基础医学组较差率为3.8%， “创新性与论文价值”上军事管理组较差率为5.6%，“基础知识与科研能力掌握”上基础医学组较差率为2.5%，“论文规范性”上军事管理组较差率为1.9%。结论　论文选题是学位论文的质量关键，基础医学和军事管理组应提高学位论文选题科学性和论文规范性

Abstract

Objective　To investigate the quality of dissertations by analyzing the concealed evaluation results of postgraduate dissertations

and to provide a reference for improving the quality of dissertations. Methods　A total of 366 postgraduate dissertations and 1 051 concealed evaluation comments were collected from a medical university

and according to the evaluation index system of postgraduate dissertations

a horizontal comparison was made based on the overall quality and discipline. Excel and SPSS 19.0 were used for statistical analysis. Results　Eighty percent of the dissertations in unqualified category had poor topic selection

and the excellent and good rate was only 21% in Standardability. In discipline-based evaluations

the basic medicine group had a poor rate of 3.8% in Topic Selection and 2.5% in Mastery of Basic Knowledge and Scientific Research Ability

while the military management group had a poor rate of 5.6% in Innovation and Value and 1.9% in Standardability. Conclusion　Topic selection is the key to the quality of dissertations

and the groups of basic medicine and military management should improve the scientificity of topic selection and the standardability of dissertations.

关键词

医学院校　学位论文　盲审

Keywords

Medical university　Dissertation　Concealed evaluation

references

Views

930

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

Optimized enrollment strategies of medical universities based on factors influencing students' selection of university in filling rank order list of College Entrance Examination

Humanities quality education in college English teaching at medical colleges and universities

Practice and discussion of German as a second language teaching at medical colleges and universities

Related Author

Luo Youhui

Hou Jianlin

Wang Dan

张艳

杨秋宁

Related Institution

Office of Education, Peking University Health Science Center

Institute of Medical Education & National Center for Health Professions Education Development, Peking University

⁰