Another analysis method of VARK questionnaire results based on medical students in shanghai and it’s empirical application

您当前的位置：

首页 >

文章列表页 >

Another analysis method of VARK questionnaire results based on medical students in shanghai and it’s empirical application

更新时间：2024-09-19

- Another analysis method of VARK questionnaire results based on medical students in shanghai and it’s empirical application
- Vol. 17, Issue 10, (2018)
- 作者机构：
  
  海军军医大学职业教育中心（鲁娟），校长办公室（刘斌）,上海
- 作者简介：
- 基金信息：
- DOI：
  CLC：
- Published：2018，
- 稿件说明：
移动端阅览
Another analysis method of VARK questionnaire results based on medical students in shanghai and it’s empirical application. [J]. 17(10).(2018)
DOI：

Another analysis method of VARK questionnaire results based on medical students in shanghai and it’s empirical application. [J]. 17(10).(2018) DOI：

摘要

目的　弥补VARK量表作者原有分类方法信息损失较大的不足（尤其是对于混合风格），提出另一种“基于是否包含”原则的分类方法，并进行实证应用和分析。方法　2017年5月，应用VARK 7.0，调查上海市4所医学院校学生的感官学习风格；共发放4 488份，回收有效问卷4 054份（90.3%）。使用SPSS 20.0，计数资料的比较采用卡方检验。结果　①学生总体感官学习风格类型包含视觉性者占44.8%（1 815人）。不同院校层次、院校类型、性别、专业、是否军校的学生数据差异无统计学意义（χ2=5.958，0.257，1.386，5.922，4.146；P=0.051，0.612，0.239，0.052，0.042）。不同年级学生的数据差异有统计学意义（χ2=13.400，P=0.009）。②学生总体包含听觉型者占57.1%（2 313人）。不同性别、专业、年级、是否军校的学生数据差异无统计学意义（ χ2=0.536，4.038，8.274，4.256；P=0.464，0.133，0.082，0.039）。不同院校层次、不同院校类型学生的数据差异有统计学意义（χ2=10.516，10.447；P=0.005，0.001）。③学生总体包含阅读写作型者占53.9%（2 185人）。不同院校层次、院校类型、性别、专业、年级、是否军校的学生数据差异无统计学意义（ χ2=4.563，0.417，0.228，0.433，2.136，0.863；P=0.102，0.518，0.633，0.805，0.711，0.353）。④学生总体包含运动实践型者占64.8%（2 625人）。不同院校层次、院校类型、专业、年级、是否军校的学生数据差异无统计学意义（ χ2=3.680，3.391，1.070，9.708，2.711；P=0.159，0.066，0.586，0.046，0.100）。仅不同性别学生的数据差异有统计学意义（ χ2=6.789；P=0.009）。⑤按照量表作者原来的分类方法，学生总体多重风格者最多（57.0%），其次是运动实践型（17.3%），再次是听觉型（11.2%）、阅读写作型（10.0%），最后是视觉型（4.5%）；不同院校层次、院校类型、性别、专业、年级、是否军校的学生数据差异无统计学意义（ χ2=6.044，18.045，8.575，5.955，28.866，11.622；P=0.196，0.021，0.073，0.652，0.025，0.020）。结论　基于“是否包含”的分类方法，由于体现了混合型风格的情况，包含信息更为全面和准确，结果无争议，是VARK量表作者原有分类方法在实际运用中的科学改进和和有益补充；经实证检验，验证了医学生具有与众不同的感官学习风格

Abstract

Objective　To make up for losing more information of original classification method of VARK questionnaire author (especially for mixed styles)

and put another analytical method based on whether contain or not principle and put it in empirical analysis and application. Methods　The students in 4 medial colleges in Shanghai were surveyed with VARK 7.0 version in May

2017. 4 488 questionnaires were sent out and 4 054 were effectively returned (90.3%). Statistical analyses were done with SPSS 20.0 software and the enumeration data were compared by chi-square test. Results　①The percentage of con-taining V type of Sensory Learning Styles in the whole students was 44.8% (n=1 815)

which had no statis-tical significance in different college levels

college sorts

genders

specialties and whether they were military academy students or not ( χ2=5.958

0.257

1.386

5.922

4.146; P=0.051

0.612

0.239

0.052

0.042)

while there was significantly statistical difference in data among students of different grades ( χ2=13.400; P=0.009). ②The percentage of containing A type was 57.1% (n=2 313)

which had no statistical significance in different genders

specialties

grades and whether they were military academy students ( χ2=0.536

4.038

8.274

4.256; P=0.464

0.133

0.082

0.039)

while there was still statistical significance in different college levels and sorts ( χ2=10.516

10.447; P=0.005

0.001). ③The percentage of containing R type was 53.9% (n=2 185)

which had no statistical significance in different college levels

college sorts

genders

specialties

grades and whether they were academy students( χ2=4.563

0.417

0.228

0.433

2.136

0.863; P=0.102

0.518

0.633

0.805

0.711

0.353). ④The percentage of containing K type was 64.8% (n=2 625)

which had no statistical significance in different college levels

college sorts

specialties

grades and whether they were academy students ( χ2=3.680

3.391

1.070

9.708

2.711; P=0.159

0.066

0.586

0.046

0.100)

while there was still statistical significance in different genders (　 χ2=6.789; P=0.009). ⑤According to original clas-sification of VARK questionnaire author

the percentage of mixed styles were at the most (57.0%)

followed by K (17.3%)

and then A (11.2%) and R (10.0%)

and the least was V (4.5%)

which had no sta-tistical significance in different college levels

college sorts

genders

specialties

grades and whether they were academy students (　 χ2=6.044

18.045

8.575

5.955

28.866

11.622; P=0.196

0.021

0.073

0.652

0.025

0.020). Conclusion　The analytical classification method based on whether to contain is a scientific improvement and beneficial supplement to the original classification method of the author of VARK scale in practical application because it embodies the mixed style and contains more comprehensive and accurate information. And through the empirical test

it verifies that medical students have distinctive sensory learn-ing styles.

关键词

VARK　上海市　医学生　分析方法　实证应用

Keywords

VARK　Shanghai　Medical students　Analytical method　Empirical application

references

Views

834

下载量

CSCD

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Tools

Publicity Resources

Exploration of English newspaper reading activities for medical students

A comparative study of conventional teaching program and logical thinking ability training program for ultrasonic medical students

Application of heuristic teaching in film-reading session of radiology education for medical students

Empathy levels among medical students in a military medical university and the influencing factors

Research progress of early clinical exposure in medical colleges and Universities in China: A review

Related Author

邹漫云　单丽英

周月红　郭瑞强

朱捷　邹明珠　陈起航　周诚

樊博宇张静

李艳超1　朴杰2 　徐嘉鸣1　王真1　李勇2　曹德品1

马英　王建

符晓华

陈兴书

Related Institution

海军军医大学护理学院

哈尔滨医科大学教务处

哈尔滨医科大学公共卫生学院

锦州医科大学马克思主义学院

湖南省教育厅研究项目

⁰